@Real_Obsi I'm not going to give you a detailed response, because it's pretty clear that unlike @Bolt_Strike, you clearly aren't interested in having a level-headed discussion about this. (I could tell that just by reading your last like 5 comments.) I highly doubt you read very much of what I had to say, but I ask that you do. Please try to learn and expand your clearly narrow worldview. Trust me, it's more interesting that way. I'm not responding to any replies you post.
@Bolt_Strike https://x.com/MetalDragonKid/status/1748952701071655171 He was talking about Buzzfeed using AI, not he himself using it. And it makes sense why that would be on his mind, considering his company was working on a very Pokemon-like game. And if you scroll through the replies of the tweet there's a lot of people making good points about how Palworld certainly didn't use AI. One of the most compelling reasons is them not disclosing on the Steam page for the game, which I believe is required for games that use AI. And yeah you could say they're lying, but I would be shocked if Valve didn't do their research when this controversy started. And yet the game remains up, showing Valve didn't have any solid evidence either. I'm gonna quote your comment really quick for clarity, but I don't KNOW how to use the quote feature.
"It was a few months after Palworld's announcement, but close enough to be believable that he used the same process for the official designs. His comments on supporting AI, this tweet showing he's done AI-generated Pokemon, and the official designs including elements of Pokemon should be enough evidence for a copyright infringement claim."
Then why haven't they? Nintendo and Pokemon have one of the most skilled legal teams out there. So, if they had even the slightest case to make they would have. I'll tell you why they haven't, because there's no proof. So unless we're using a guilty based off of no evidence until proven innocent justice system, there is no question here.
@Bolt_Strike That's funny because I've clicked through probably a dozen sources and none of them have any evidence to support the claim ai was used. Yes, the CEO is a fan of generative AI, but that is not real evidence for its use. In addition, the game was in development and character designs were shown off before generative AI was much of a thing, and definitely before AI would have been good enough to generate the creatures in the game. And also, if there was real evidence for this, Nintendo would definitely sue for that instead of patent infringement (since patent lawsuits can take forever to play out.) From what I've seen, the only people who say the creature designs were created with AI are Pokemon fanboys trying to find a reason to hate the game. Also, here's an actual source of this claim being denied by people at Pocketpair in case you are curious. https://www.gamesradar.com/games/survival/palworld-community-lead-says-really-we-didnt-ai-generate-any-pals-and-no-lawsuit-ever-existed-following-viral-pokemon-comparisons/
@Dr_Lugae I think you hit the nail on the head with that last part. Pocketpair likely wouldn't care too much about having to change character designs, but having to change gameplay mechanics would be a pain.
But in all seriousness, I really hope they go all out. We've been desperate for some Nintendo news for a while now, and I hope this is the time we see it.
@Real_Obsi Yeah, honestly I got so tired of those people. Basically any YouTuber with "Switch" in their name was claiming the Switch OLED dock would have a graphical upgrade, which was hilariously dumb. I agree though, ruins the fun for everyone, especially the people who don't know any better and get caught up in believing it's true.
@Zequio I mean it would be interesting I suppose but it's not remotely realistic. I'm sorry if I sound annoyed, but I've been reading these theories about "enhanced docks" since like 2021 (mainly from YouTubers who have no idea what they're talking about.) But it's just an incredibly silly idea that would be very expensive and reap little benefit. Also of course they have a patent, they literally have a patent for every possible idea relating to the Switch. I do think it would be kinda fun, but it would never actually be effective or make sense really.
Edit: I also am probably misreading, but the Switch does not have separate chips for handheld and docked. That would be incorrect. I assume I'm misreading tho
I'm also unfortunately amongst the crowd that found this one disappointing. The main problem was the difficulty. It was just way too easy, which is a major detriment for a strategy game imo. Also had inferiorbosses to the original and random encounters that were just pointless. Shame too cause it had a really cool battle system.
@Zequio Cause it doesn't make sense tech-wise at all. Having an additional chip would be extremely cumbersome and just probably make development for the console harder than it needs to be. I assume by chip you mean GPU correct? (It's what most people mean when they say chip) So it's going to have two of the most expensive component for basically no gain? I'm just saying, there's a reason no one builds PCs with two graphics cards, and a reason you wouldn't put two in a console. That just doesn't help.
That being said, it will almost certainly perform better in docked mode, because it'll likely be underclocked in handheld to conserve battery life.
There was a point when I cared about this game, but at this point I just don't anymore. I can only wait so long for a game I am only slightly interested in.
@anoyonmus I don't think Mariokart style tilt controls would help much then, considering the problem revolves around your acceleration amount being determined by how far the triggers are held down. I do think the concept of linking Xbox controllers to Switch is fascinating though, and feels like it would be an obvious next step for Microsoft. They already have the most popular controller for PC, so maybe they could just become "king of the controller market" or something by making PS5 and Switch compatible contollers.
@anoyonmus I don't really know how tilt controls would fix the problem (I'm not really familiar with Asphalt 9). I feel like they'd have to come up with some solution though, right? I mean, is there anything stopping third-party companies from producing controllers with analogue triggers? Otherwise I don't know if it's a fixable issue, cause the game is VERY heavily built around them. I know I definitely wouldn't play it without the triggers, that's for sure.
I mean, it would be awesome to have portably, and I'm pretty sure the Switch 2 can handle it since it's available on Xbox One. The issue is as others have mentioned, it's basically unplayable without analogue triggers, so unless that's a Switch 2 feature yet to be leaked, there's really no point.
This whole mentality of "Switch 2 needs to be different" personally annoys me to no end. Nintendo's cramming in of unnecessary gimmicks has gotten on my nerves for a long time. It is legitimately hard to go back and play the wii and DS (even with the nostalgia I have for them) because it feels like every game has some shoehorned motion or touchscreen gimmick. Not to mention, their "fearless ambition" as some refer to it has often alienated third party developers (The GameCube and N64 had rather lackluster third party support because with cartridges and mini discs, Nintendo decided to be different just for the sake of being different). And I think judging a console based on its "charmingness" is kinda stupid.
I think this is a little extreme. Especially in this case where there really wasn't much to spoil. Also, if Nintendo wanted no leaks, maybe they shouldn't have waited an absurdly long time to reveal it.
@Tanookduke That's what I'm wondering. Mario maker for level designing perhaps? COD when that comes to the system? Sim games like Civ 7? So many possibilities.
Very slick trailer. Nothing too mind blowing, but very smooth and a smart way to introduce the new console. Also, love that console design. The black with accents is perfect.
@SilentBluntman It's okay, I can disagree with more than one person. It's not offensive. In fact, I find your actions to be the more offensive. As someone who is physically disabled, it's incredibly annoying when people throw the term ableism at everything. It actively devalues the term. Save your outrage for something or someone that actually deserves it. Trust me, there's a lot worse out there.
@SilentBluntman Is it the couch potatoes line? That's the only thing I found that seemed ableism related. If so, you and I have very different definitions of ableism.
@Qwiff I don't know if I agree. I actually played tropical freeze first and then Returns, and I found things to like about both. Tropical Freeze offers far more level variety and intricate level design, but Returns is far more challenging. I would hardly say there is little reason to go back.
@Mana_Knight It does seem to be the common consensus that DK is Diddy Kong's uncle, though some family trees do list hem as cousins. The justification of this is unclear.
@Bumb_Ditch Well made? I dunno man. Terrible frame rate, boring dungeon design, very passive and uninteresting combat are all things I don't associate with "well made" games. Also, not really comparable to the CDI games. Those were bad, this one's just average. You can't honestly tell me if this was some random indie game it would be anywhere near this GOTY conversation.
@nomither6 The company that owns the engine no longer exists. They were absorbed into EA. So, they would need to renegotiate a (likely expensive) new deal to use it. They could always rebuild in a new engine, but that would be a significant amount of work. It's why the game isn't on Steam. Very unfortunate all around.
Comments 638
Re: Talking Point: Nintendo Direct Predictions - What Do You Want To See?
Prime 2 and 3 would be awesome.
Re: Forget The Lawsuit, Pocketpair Says Palworld On Switch 2 Is "100% Worth Considering"
@Real_Obsi I'm not going to give you a detailed response, because it's pretty clear that unlike @Bolt_Strike, you clearly aren't interested in having a level-headed discussion about this. (I could tell that just by reading your last like 5 comments.) I highly doubt you read very much of what I had to say, but I ask that you do. Please try to learn and expand your clearly narrow worldview. Trust me, it's more interesting that way. I'm not responding to any replies you post.
Re: Forget The Lawsuit, Pocketpair Says Palworld On Switch 2 Is "100% Worth Considering"
@Bolt_Strike https://x.com/MetalDragonKid/status/1748952701071655171
He was talking about Buzzfeed using AI, not he himself using it. And it makes sense why that would be on his mind, considering his company was working on a very Pokemon-like game. And if you scroll through the replies of the tweet there's a lot of people making good points about how Palworld certainly didn't use AI. One of the most compelling reasons is them not disclosing on the Steam page for the game, which I believe is required for games that use AI. And yeah you could say they're lying, but I would be shocked if Valve didn't do their research when this controversy started. And yet the game remains up, showing Valve didn't have any solid evidence either. I'm gonna quote your comment really quick for clarity, but I don't KNOW how to use the quote feature.
"It was a few months after Palworld's announcement, but close enough to be believable that he used the same process for the official designs. His comments on supporting AI, this tweet showing he's done AI-generated Pokemon, and the official designs including elements of Pokemon should be enough evidence for a copyright infringement claim."
Then why haven't they? Nintendo and Pokemon have one of the most skilled legal teams out there. So, if they had even the slightest case to make they would have. I'll tell you why they haven't, because there's no proof. So unless we're using a guilty based off of no evidence until proven innocent justice system, there is no question here.
Re: Forget The Lawsuit, Pocketpair Says Palworld On Switch 2 Is "100% Worth Considering"
@Bolt_Strike That's funny because I've clicked through probably a dozen sources and none of them have any evidence to support the claim ai was used. Yes, the CEO is a fan of generative AI, but that is not real evidence for its use. In addition, the game was in development and character designs were shown off before generative AI was much of a thing, and definitely before AI would have been good enough to generate the creatures in the game. And also, if there was real evidence for this, Nintendo would definitely sue for that instead of patent infringement (since patent lawsuits can take forever to play out.) From what I've seen, the only people who say the creature designs were created with AI are Pokemon fanboys trying to find a reason to hate the game. Also, here's an actual source of this claim being denied by people at Pocketpair in case you are curious.
https://www.gamesradar.com/games/survival/palworld-community-lead-says-really-we-didnt-ai-generate-any-pals-and-no-lawsuit-ever-existed-following-viral-pokemon-comparisons/
Re: Forget The Lawsuit, Pocketpair Says Palworld On Switch 2 Is "100% Worth Considering"
@Dr_Lugae I think you hit the nail on the head with that last part. Pocketpair likely wouldn't care too much about having to change character designs, but having to change gameplay mechanics would be a pain.
Re: Forget The Lawsuit, Pocketpair Says Palworld On Switch 2 Is "100% Worth Considering"
@swoose Well yeah, but it was never realistic for Palworld to release and run well on Switch. Not every game can.
Re: Forget The Lawsuit, Pocketpair Says Palworld On Switch 2 Is "100% Worth Considering"
@Bolt_Strike There is quite literally zero evidence they used AI for the monster designs. That is blatant misinformation.
Re: PSA: Be Careful, These Light-Up Joy-Con Look As Dodgy As They Come
I don't know about everyone else, but weird uncanny valley AI images freak me the heck out.
Re: Nintendo Places Outside Top 20 In Metacritic's 15th Annual Game Publisher Rankings
Sega at one? Year of Shadow just keeps winning.
Re: Talking Point: What We Expect From The Switch 2 Direct
But in all seriousness, I really hope they go all out. We've been desperate for some Nintendo news for a while now, and I hope this is the time we see it.
Re: Talking Point: What We Expect From The Switch 2 Direct
How is Hi-Fi Rush port only at .9 percent? Shame on you all.
Re: Rumour: Switch 2 3D Dock Mock-Up Surfaces Online
@Real_Obsi Yeah, honestly I got so tired of those people. Basically any YouTuber with "Switch" in their name was claiming the Switch OLED dock would have a graphical upgrade, which was hilariously dumb. I agree though, ruins the fun for everyone, especially the people who don't know any better and get caught up in believing it's true.
Re: Rumour: Switch 2 3D Dock Mock-Up Surfaces Online
@Zequio Yeah I assumed I was misreading lol.
Re: Rumour: Switch 2 3D Dock Mock-Up Surfaces Online
@Zequio I mean it would be interesting I suppose but it's not remotely realistic. I'm sorry if I sound annoyed, but I've been reading these theories about "enhanced docks" since like 2021 (mainly from YouTubers who have no idea what they're talking about.) But it's just an incredibly silly idea that would be very expensive and reap little benefit. Also of course they have a patent, they literally have a patent for every possible idea relating to the Switch. I do think it would be kinda fun, but it would never actually be effective or make sense really.
Edit: I also am probably misreading, but the Switch does not have separate chips for handheld and docked. That would be incorrect. I assume I'm misreading tho
Re: Mario + Rabbids Director Recalls "Harsh" Ubisoft Comment On 'Sparks Of Hope'
@Keyblade-Dan This
Re: Mario + Rabbids Director Recalls "Harsh" Ubisoft Comment On 'Sparks Of Hope'
I'm also unfortunately amongst the crowd that found this one disappointing. The main problem was the difficulty. It was just way too easy, which is a major detriment for a strategy game imo. Also had inferiorbosses to the original and random encounters that were just pointless. Shame too cause it had a really cool battle system.
Re: Rumour: Switch 2 3D Dock Mock-Up Surfaces Online
@Zequio Cause it doesn't make sense tech-wise at all. Having an additional chip would be extremely cumbersome and just probably make development for the console harder than it needs to be. I assume by chip you mean GPU correct? (It's what most people mean when they say chip) So it's going to have two of the most expensive component for basically no gain? I'm just saying, there's a reason no one builds PCs with two graphics cards, and a reason you wouldn't put two in a console. That just doesn't help.
That being said, it will almost certainly perform better in docked mode, because it'll likely be underclocked in handheld to conserve battery life.
Re: Rumour: Switch 2 3D Dock Mock-Up Surfaces Online
@MrCarlos46 There isn't going to be any "graphical boost" in the dock. That's not how the dock works.
Re: Talking Point: Can Nintendo Keep Up The One-Game-A-Month Release Pace On Switch 2?
@Grumblevolcano At least it would make more sense than it does for Sony. A lot of Nintendo's first party games could probably use a remaster honestly.
Re: Balatro's New Free Update Features Crossovers With Assassin's Creed, Fallout, Civ And More
Dang, those are some big crossovers. How'd he manage to pull that off?
Re: Super Mario NES Banger Joins Nintendo's Music App, Here's The Full Tracklist
Oh hey, it's the game of the year 27 years in a row. How about that.
Re: Talking Point: The 3DS Library Is Ripe For Switch 2, But Is NSO The Way To Go?
Oh great, an article to draw in the 2 most annoying kinds of people. The NSO haters and the Kid Icarus uprising fanboys. Wonderfull.
Re: Tales Of The Shire, The Cosy LOTR Game, Has Been Delayed Again
There was a point when I cared about this game, but at this point I just don't anymore. I can only wait so long for a game I am only slightly interested in.
Re: Feature: 12 Things Switch 2's Mysterious Not-C-Button Might Do, Maybe
I'm personally rooting for the open Google sheets button.
Re: Rumour: Switch 2 Game Cases Might Take Up More Space On Your Shelf
Hehehe big boxes make brain go brrrrr.
Re: Rumour: Another Xbox Game Could Be Racing Onto Switch 2, It's Claimed
@anoyonmus I don't think Mariokart style tilt controls would help much then, considering the problem revolves around your acceleration amount being determined by how far the triggers are held down. I do think the concept of linking Xbox controllers to Switch is fascinating though, and feels like it would be an obvious next step for Microsoft. They already have the most popular controller for PC, so maybe they could just become "king of the controller market" or something by making PS5 and Switch compatible contollers.
Re: Rumour: Another Xbox Game Could Be Racing Onto Switch 2, It's Claimed
@anoyonmus I don't really know how tilt controls would fix the problem (I'm not really familiar with Asphalt 9). I feel like they'd have to come up with some solution though, right? I mean, is there anything stopping third-party companies from producing controllers with analogue triggers? Otherwise I don't know if it's a fixable issue, cause the game is VERY heavily built around them. I know I definitely wouldn't play it without the triggers, that's for sure.
Re: Rumour: Another Xbox Game Could Be Racing Onto Switch 2, It's Claimed
I mean, it would be awesome to have portably, and I'm pretty sure the Switch 2 can handle it since it's available on Xbox One. The issue is as others have mentioned, it's basically unplayable without analogue triggers, so unless that's a Switch 2 feature yet to be leaked, there's really no point.
Re: Mailbox: Switch 2 Caution, Unpopular Opinions, Easy Games - Nintendo Life Letters
This whole mentality of "Switch 2 needs to be different" personally annoys me to no end. Nintendo's cramming in of unnecessary gimmicks has gotten on my nerves for a long time. It is legitimately hard to go back and play the wii and DS (even with the nostalgia I have for them) because it feels like every game has some shoehorned motion or touchscreen gimmick. Not to mention, their "fearless ambition" as some refer to it has often alienated third party developers (The GameCube and N64 had rather lackluster third party support because with cartridges and mini discs, Nintendo decided to be different just for the sake of being different). And I think judging a console based on its "charmingness" is kinda stupid.
Re: Banjo-Kazooie Has The Potential To "Rival 3D Mario", Says Ori Dev
Sell similar numbers? Somebody's on the hopium big time.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Donkey Kong Country Returns HD?
@Lord The game does have an easy mode though? Also lets you skip stages if you die enough times, so I'm not sure what you're on about.
Re: Round Up: Video Game Industry Reacts To Nintendo's Switch 2 Announcement
Oh my goodness Lucid mentioned!!! I'm really looking forward to that game. (David Wise on the OST btw.)
Re: Random: Switch 2 Leakers Called Out By Industry Veteran Hideki Kamiya
I think this is a little extreme. Especially in this case where there really wasn't much to spoil. Also, if Nintendo wanted no leaks, maybe they shouldn't have waited an absurdly long time to reveal it.
Re: Joy-Con Mouse Functionality Seemingly Confirmed In Switch 2 Trailer
@Tanookduke That's what I'm wondering. Mario maker for level designing perhaps? COD when that comes to the system? Sim games like Civ 7? So many possibilities.
Re: Switch 2 Will Be Backwards Compatible With Physical And Digital Games, With Some Exceptions
@Dimey I wouldn't be too worried about that personally. Nintendo's cloud saves genuinely work very well.
Re: Poll: So, What Did You Think Of The Switch 2 Reveal?
Very slick trailer. Nothing too mind blowing, but very smooth and a smart way to introduce the new console. Also, love that console design. The black with accents is perfect.
Re: Switch Online's Missions & Rewards Adds Donkey Kong Country Returns HD Icons
I actually am a big fan of the one with the Kongs in the minecart. Mihht actually use it.
Re: The Switch eShop Is A Nightmare, So We've Made Our Own "Better eShop"
Removed
Re: The Switch eShop Is A Nightmare, So We've Made Our Own "Better eShop"
@SilentBluntman It's okay, I can disagree with more than one person. It's not offensive. In fact, I find your actions to be the more offensive. As someone who is physically disabled, it's incredibly annoying when people throw the term ableism at everything. It actively devalues the term. Save your outrage for something or someone that actually deserves it. Trust me, there's a lot worse out there.
Re: The Switch eShop Is A Nightmare, So We've Made Our Own "Better eShop"
@SilentBluntman Is it the couch potatoes line? That's the only thing I found that seemed ableism related. If so, you and I have very different definitions of ableism.
Re: The Switch eShop Is A Nightmare, So We've Made Our Own "Better eShop"
@SilentBluntman Which review was this? I would be curious to read it myself.
Re: Review: Donkey Kong Country Returns HD (Switch) - Aping A Retro Classic
@Qwiff I don't know if I agree. I actually played tropical freeze first and then Returns, and I found things to like about both. Tropical Freeze offers far more level variety and intricate level design, but Returns is far more challenging. I would hardly say there is little reason to go back.
Re: Review: Donkey Kong Country Returns HD (Switch) - Aping A Retro Classic
@Mana_Knight It does seem to be the common consensus that DK is Diddy Kong's uncle, though some family trees do list hem as cousins. The justification of this is unclear.
Re: 'Nintendo Music' Adds Another Legendary Zelda Soundtrack, Here's Every Song Included
Heck yeah! Might not be the biggest fan of the game personally, but the OST is simply one of the best of all time.
Re: Rumour: Ubisoft Has "More Than Half A Dozen Games" Planned For Switch 2
Dang, we already getting shovelware revealed for the Switch 2? Crazy.
Re: Square Enix May Withhold Its Own Products If You Harrass Its Staff
Don't harass staff people. Never a cool thing to do.
Re: Rumour: 'Switch 2' Will Reportedly Be Officially Revealed This Thursday
Why in the world would it be Thursday? The same day Donkey Kong releases? Nintendo is very mysterious indeed.
Re: Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom Has Been Nominated For Another Award
@Bumb_Ditch Well made? I dunno man. Terrible frame rate, boring dungeon design, very passive and uninteresting combat are all things I don't associate with "well made" games. Also, not really comparable to the CDI games. Those were bad, this one's just average. You can't honestly tell me if this was some random indie game it would be anywhere near this GOTY conversation.
Re: Sonic's Next Movie Outings Could Go Beyond Earth To New "Fantastical Zones"
@nomither6 Can't say I feel the same about that era, but I agree it's a bummer of a situation.
Re: Sonic's Next Movie Outings Could Go Beyond Earth To New "Fantastical Zones"
@nomither6 The company that owns the engine no longer exists. They were absorbed into EA. So, they would need to renegotiate a (likely expensive) new deal to use it. They could always rebuild in a new engine, but that would be a significant amount of work. It's why the game isn't on Steam. Very unfortunate all around.