You don’t need to look very long at Legend of the Skyfish to know which series it takes influence from. Heck, the clue is in the name itself. Taking place on a set of islands, you take on the role of Little Red Hook, a girl with a particular talent of traversing the land and vanquishing foes with – of all things – a fishing rod. She sets out with the wise Moonwhale to defeat the monstrous Skyfish, a legendary evil that awakens after some fisherman decided to cast their line in forbidden waters.
The game is a blatant take on The Legend of Zelda, featuring familiar puzzles that require you to use your fishing rod as both a weapon and a grappling hook. You’ll need to press multiple switches, unlock various gates, plunder hidden items before destroying each island’s mystical totem.
Your items are upgradable at various points of the game, granting bonuses such as improved speed for your grappling hook, and a longer range for your melee attacks. There’s little opportunity for exploration, as the game’s islands essentially act as individual levels, with linear progression via a rudimentary overworld.
The main problem with the game is that is just doesn’t provide even a modicum of challenge from start to finish. You can figure out every puzzle within moments of encountering them, and the various enemies move so slowly that you can avoid and defeat them without breaking much of a sweat.
It’s a shame, because the game looks quite nice, and with tighter controls and a bit more thought into the puzzle design, it could have been a decent alternative to the Zelda games. As it is, it’s merely a poor imitation.
Comments 33
When they said poor man's Zelda i thought they meant the price not the quality of the game!
Was slightly interested in this title when I saw it on the eShop, glad I read this review before I wasted any money on it...
Doesnt even look like Zelda -.-
Eh, it doesn’t look that interesting in my opinion.
When what's essentially a re-hash that isn't even out yet has more soul and originality than your take on the same game.... you're doing it wrong.
@earthb0und I agree with you. This review doesn't allow for it to stand on its own and the main complaint was that "it was too easy". Really? Maybe the game is meant for......children, perhaps? A "4" is wayyyy too harsh of a score if the story and graphics were good.
I hope future reviews don't rely on this Zelda comparison. Sheesh.
2 Zelda clones in 2 weeks?
@Magrane @earthb0und
Even without the Zelda comparison (which is fair, it's aping Zelda through and through), the lack of challenge is a fair criticism. If you're going to have puzzles be an integral part of the gameplay, they need to take more than three seconds to figure out.
I keep considering picking up Blossom Tales on sales to scratch that Zelda itch (I’ve been on the fence). I’m always down for another Zelda-like but from the looks of this I should definitely get Blossom Tales before even considering this.
I bought it after seeing an 80 on metacritic. Surprised it’s a 4 according to NLife
@KoiTenchi Blossom Tales is an absolutely delightful game and will 100% scratch any Zelda itch you're having. I can't recommend it enough.
@earthb0und I thought Ittle Dew 1 and 2 had some pretty challenging puzzles, I certainly didn't know what I was doing the moment I stepped foot in the door. Had to play around quite a lot.
The game is a decent phone diversion but doesn't have enough meat to be a console release. In the Wii U days, we took what we could get. But the standard for indie releases on the switch is an order of magnitude greater.
I was eyeing this too. Sad to see it's not that good.
@Magrane its a decent, though repetitive game but it isn't braindead. I played on mobile. Can't wait to see the zelda bias show when genshin impact gets released. Is the guy who broke his PS4 in protest right?
Is this not a puzzle game? So apart from the graphical style why is this being compared to zelda??
@NintendoByNature
It's a pretty awful review and goes against the grain of nearly every other review in which it gets 6
@suikoden interesting, thanks maybe ill check it out.
@NintendoByNature
Just seems another pretentious / click bait review from Nintendo life. Seems more and more of these types of reviews
Saw this on sale and thought the fishing mechanic looked cool and honestly would have got it if this was early day switch with a small library but there are so many different games now I couldn't buy another game I won't have time to play.
Agree with the commentors above. Reading this review is frustrating. Hardly find any objective opinion here, giving the game a chance to stand in its own spotlight. Definitely not used to seeing a review of this quality on this website and I hope I don't have to get used to it
This game has been released a while ago as on iOS as many devs bringing their iOS games to switch, so going by App Store reviews I’m surprised about the low rating as it’s well received there. But this is a mobile game and I personally think it’s one of the many mobile titles that don’t need to be on switch
looks like a sad small game....
@KoiTenchi Blossom Tales is really good!
@earthb0und no. You have to compare. And if it sucks in comparison, trying to be what it's not, it sucks. People are allowed to compare games. Especially if they try to be of the same kind. We are not talking about music. My thanks to NL. Sorry for the developers. But they know. Try harder next time.
Pictures of the game surely don't look like Zelda.
Im still waiting on the physical release of Blossom Tales 🙂
@MrVariant thank you for that - and yes that release will be interesting.
@Whalehome what did you think of the game? Closer to Metacritic?
The art style looked like a dud, anyway. We'll stick with Zelda
really looks like meh
@RiggsHB it seems I’ve unfortunately missed the sale but I’ll definitely have to pick it up. I keep hearing good things. The only real thing that’s been holding me back at this point is the size of my backlog so I figure no harm in waiting for a sale again.
I hear ya. I have 200+ games on my Switch right now and I keep buying games when they go on sale. I'm drowning over here!
@Magrane it’s not an 80 (like it says on Metacritic) but it’s not a 4 (according to NLife). I’ve played about 30-45 min. I’d think a game would be more broken if it had a 4 or would be a lot less fun. It’s like a 5.5 - 6 range. It’s low challenge so far. I’ve played through the first 15 stages.
Expected as much.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...