Mahjong is a tile-based game that is utterly steeped in history and mystery – nobody really knows how old it is, as many different sources claim different dates of conception, and it seems nobody's keen to agree any time soon. This Chinese game is highly regarded in the East, but its presence in the West is significantly less pronounced. Does Best of Mahjong do this ancient and enigmatic game of tiles justice?
To clarify, this is not traditional mahjong, this is a variant of the game developed for a single-player experience called Mahjong Solitaire, but it's been around for a long time just like its predecessor. For anyone who is unfamiliar with the rules of Mahjong Solitaire, the aim of the game is to pair up and remove tiles that are horizontally adjacent to an empty space on the same level. It's simple to pick up and difficult to master, but you probably wouldn't know that if you just played this game. Despite its sister title Best of Solitaire providing ample explanation for all the variations that it supplies, Best of Mahjong entirely omits any instructions for how to play in game.
In this day and age it's easy to search the internet for this sort of information, but it still seems a glaring oversight to leave it out of the game itself. If you delve into the electronic manual you will find a poorly-worded explanation that vaguely describes how to play the game, but a lot of the aspects that the text refers to is very unclear. Luckily if you're really struggling you can turn on a system that highlights all tiles that are available to be paired, but this feels very much like hand-holding and detracts from the fun of the game.
Disregarding imperfect instructions, Best of Mahjong is just about as much as you could hope for from a game such as this; you control it using the touch screen to tap on one tile after another in order to pair them up and remove them from play. 404 different tile arrangements makes this a hugely versatile and expansive experience, and you'll likely never play the same layout twice unless you specifically choose to do so. Despite this variety, there's no actual change in gameplay unlike in Best of Solitaire, so even though you've got as many different layouts as you like you're still going to be playing the same game no matter what you do. Nevetheless, Mahjong is a frighteningly addictive experience, and as soon as you're able to recognise the different tiles at a glance you'll be pairing tiles like a whirlwind.
The presentation is functional, but doesn't really offer anything particularly exciting. The top and bottom screens disiplay essentially the same thing, but the 3D effect on the top screen is a nice little touch – even if you do end up looking at the bottom screen all the time. The music is repetitive and a little bit irritating, but there's nothing to stop you from simply turning the volume off and listening to your personal choice of sounds on a different device.
Don't expect to win this game over and over, either, as it's largely down to the luck of its layout by its very nature. This can be disheartening, but the satisfaction of finally getting a board cleared of tiles is all the more fulfilling for it. The 3DS title can't be blamed for this fact, as it's an integral part of the original game, and to change this would be tantamount to sacrilege.
Conclusion
Best of Mahjong is a great game to get into the interesting world of mahjong, but may put off those who have difficulty getting to grips with it at first; despite the almost complete lack of instructions, once you get to grips with this title you'll find it difficult to put down.Those expecting the original game designed for multiple people may be disappointed by its distinctly solo environment, but otherwise it's an excellent little budget title for some Eastern solo fun.
Comments 15
You can play this game for free on your computer.
I've got a couple of questions for you, Alex. I am very picky about solitaire mahjong games and they have to have specific features before I'd even consider getting one.
My first question has already been answered as the only layout I usually ever play is the traditional Turtle. LOTS of new Mahjong games these days apparently don't have this layout (WHY?) which annoys me greatly. EVERY OLD game I've played has Turtle, which makes it more baffling why new games don't.
Secondly, I really hate how tiles that can be removed (whether they can be matched or not) are highlighted (at at least appear much brighter than tiles that are not) on the screen. It's one of the many features in newer games that I despise because it's essentially considered cheating (much like shuffle) in my eyes. Does this game do it too? If it's an OPTIONAL feature, then that's fine, just as long as it's not mandatory. Some of those screenshots you've posted doesn't bode well though, cause I see tiles that are clearly darkened in several screens.
Does the game tell you when you've ran out of matches? Normally this would be a standard in any game, but I've actually ran across one game that -didn't.- I never shuffle (it's cheating) so if a game tells me there's no more matches, then I can simply start a new game.
Thanks for answering my questions (if you do anyway).
@Kirby_Fan_DL3 Just 'cause you can play it 'for free' on a PC doesn't mean all the other 'non free' games aren't worth playing, or aren't as good, if not better. I can play Space Cadet on PC for free, but then I could also play The Pinball Arcade on PC (it's not free) that's 1000% better than Space Cadet. I can't bring my PC with me when I go out too so being able to play a similar game for free on another system is hugely irrelevant and not a good argument. Portability matters to me.
Meh jong.
sigh Again just Mahjong Solitaire. Can we finally get the real deal on ANY consoles in the West, please?
@Kirby_Fan_DL3
That's somewhat harsh, for that matter you can easily play GBA games for free on your computer...and on your Wii. Doesn't stop Nintendo from releasing them for 8 bucks every other week.
@Donjwolf When you run out of matches, the game asks you if you want to start a new game or shuffle. Shuffling adds 10 seconds to your time.
By default, no tiles are highlighted, but the lower layers get slightly darker to make it easier to perceive depth. The highlighting removable tiles is optional. It's a feature I love and the dsiware version didn't have it so I remember commenting about that in a forum topic here, only to see you and the review for this version mention they hate it
@jdarrell Thanks very much for your help This game sounds cool then. I'll get it sometime. Yeah sorry. I just don't like that feature
@KeeperBvK if not limited to west, Nintendo is going to release Yakuman Phoenix (3DS) on 2/18, which is free to download / limited play, and 1000 yen / 6 months for full experience. However, if you just consider in the west, I don't think it's something likely to happen.
It's hard to tell from the screens but I'd only be interested if you have multiple tile sets to choose from. the tiny differences in the traditional Mahjong tiles are too hard for me to pair up. My favorite mahjong game is Shanghai II: Dragons Eye for the SNES, and I always use either flags, alphabet or my favorite, street signs. If this has some good tile sets, I'll gladly add it to my 3DS
@Yomerodes The diifference is that free mahjong games for PC are available legally, while downloading GBA games on your PC is illegal...
@AshFoxX I don't have this exact version, but there should be three colours of the traditional tileset, a poker tileset (as seen in the screenshot), an egypt tileset (similar idea to traditional, but you can tell things apart a bit easier), and an "easy" tileset (mostly numbers).
I have the DSiWare version of this (which has a 10th of the layouts) and its my favorite mahjong game on my 3ds.
Maybe some day I'll upgrade.
Another Mahjongg game which isn't actually Mahjongg. Sigh.
I finally got around to playing it. I'll prolly download it on my mom's 3DS. She loves this stuff and also has a Majong Solitare game on her mac.
This is the best Mahjong (Solitaire) game on the 3DS.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...