In recent times we've provided some coverage of progress on a 3DS Homebrew Channel project, which is apparently all set to be released on 22nd November. It can be a grey area of fierce debate, as the excitement for some to produce apps and games — as was the case on DS and Wii — is countered by those that criticise the potential for piracy or unofficial emulators on Nintendo's hardware. Supporters of the 3DS project will no doubt emphasize that it doesn't allow users to play illegally downloaded ROMS of the portable's games, though Nintendo will still likely tackle it with system updates to block access.
There is a small but dedicated band of gamers that support and participate in homebrew, of course, and that group is causing a sudden increase in sales of Cubic Ninja. Ahead of the exploit's release on 22nd November, its programmer / hacker smealum has confirmed the 3DS cart that is required to run the channel. Setting it up requires the game, which will work with the cart in PAL regions and North America, while the eShop version is only an option in Japan.
As mentioned above, the fact that only physical copies are an option in the West has prompted a surge in sales. We've had readers get in touch to advise that the title's becoming increasingly hard to find, while on amazon.com it's improbably moved up the best sellers chart, reaching number 28 at the time of writing. As for why the exploit uses Cubic Ninja, it likely has a bug that's being utilised; as the company behind the game has folded, odds of the loophole being closed are practically non-existent.
These sales of the game show that the homebrew community is getting on board with the new project, despite the rival audience that's no doubt against the exploit's existence. In any case it's rather humorous to see a forgotten, modest 3DS game suddenly pick up improbable sales.
Let us know what you think, as always, though remember to observe our Community Rules while discussing this topic.
Thanks to all of our readers that sent this in.
Please note that some external links on this page are affiliate links, which means if you click them and make a purchase we may receive a small percentage of the sale. Please read our FTC Disclosure for more information.
Comments 78
Is number 28 on the best selling games (including all platforms) as well as number 5 on the 3DS selling chart. A bottom-of-the-bin game, that usually retailed for 10 or less, is sellling at 22 bucks, minimum!!
I got mine at gamestop for $6.
Why does that Cubic Ninja link lead to an amiibo commercial?
I just so happen to have this game actually. Got it for 5 bucks a good while ago.
@Yosher Fixed!
That's pretty cool that that specific game that nobody cared about is what is required. It does greatly limit how many people can use the new Homebrew channel though. I doubt there are many copies out there.
Oh my.
I just reserved my copy at Gamestop for only 4.99! Get it before it costs $90 used like Xenoblade!
I wonder how this will affect Nintendo's numbers. I guess we can say goodbye to a lot of possible future titles due to a drastic drop in 3DS game sales...
It's a Ubisoft game hahahahaha.
Shamed be he who thinks evil of it.
publishers of this game must be thrilled
Huh. I've had this game for a while now. It's OK.
I'm willing to bet the developers don't mind.
@TeeJay It's homebrew, not piracy. Piracy already exists on the 3ds since 2012, and Nintendo is still making games for it, so I'm sure homebrew won't change that.
All the way up to 28th best selling on all platforms, 5th on 3DS alone?
That goes to show that the homebrew scene is not trivial.
@DrkBndr Well at the moment it's just Homebrew, which is fine. I have nothing against that. But I imagine it's only a matter of time before someone figures out how to use this for piracy.
I didn't know we already had piracy in this gen. But regardless, once an exploit is discovered, I imagine it'll become a lot more accessible and will lead to a sharp spike in piracy.
Hopefully Nintendo figures out how it's going to work, and puts out an update on the 21st, required to play Pokemon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire, that closes whatever hole it uses, leaving tons of people with a useless copy of Cubic Ninja. Even if the hack's creator doesn't plan on using it for piracy of 3DS games, other people will, and even if they didn't, it still allows for piracy of other games, including those available on the eshop.
@TrueWiiMaster
Pokémon ORAS already went gold, and all the manufactured game cartridges couldn't possibly include a firmware later than 9.2, it might only have 9.0.
The most they can do is release a firmware needed to access the eShop, then to download a patch needed for online play.
That would be one way to force players to update, if they value the online play. They could probably do it for Smash Bros too, and likely will with the anticipated v1.04 balance patch.
@RupeeClock What if people have a spare 3DS lying around?
@TeeJay People will probably use one 3DS for their games, and the other for homebrew.
That's my plan actually, I old an original Aqua Blue 3DS still on firmware 4.5.
@TeeJay
Do yourself a favor and read a little bit about this topic before getting your panties in a bunch. The 3DS has been able to play pirated games for like a year already. This homebrew stuff is the least of your worries.
Also, the DS, PS2 and Wii all had huge software libraries and all of them were easily hacked. This won't effect the 3DS' ability to get new games. Take a deep breath and relax.
Still wondering though, once this exploit is out, it'll blast the doors open for others to find more holes in the system to have more homebrew. Same happened with Smash Brawl, and Twilight Princess, And cough Lego Batman.
Having a guess the exploit is going the same route that The Wii had when it got hit with the hole. It'll only be a matter of time before someone figures it all out.
As the honor of Homebrew Coders: They NEVER have or want anything to do with piracy. It's the pirates that steal from the homebrewers to use THEIR exploits against them. It'll only be a matter of time before all hell breaks loose.
Cubic Ninja 3DS
Amazon UK
1 new from £65.32
1 used from £59.95
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@TrueWiiMaster @TeeJay again, this exploit cannot lead to piracy. a new different exploit will need to be found.
there's no way that an exploit which leads to user-mode access can be used to gain the kernel-level access which would be required to run roms.
this is due to the security measures put in place by nintendo, similar to UAC on windows, where only specific processes get to have root or administrator access to the system.
this is why NL are reporting this, but have never mentioned the gateway card, which is used for piracy by most of its owners.
I love how people read "Homebrew only exploit" and immediately go "PIRACY!". If it only was this simple... 3DS has way too much security, and launching a game from SD card would require Kernel Mode access to either install it by BYPASSING LICENSE CHECK or reroute game cart reads to SD card. None of that can be done in any way on this exploit as it only grants USER MODE access
Besides, piracy on 3DS existed for quite a while now because of Gateway (4.x only), and recently a new flashcard was released that works on newest firmware.
@PewnyPL When emulators start to pop up, I guess the sales of Virtual Console games may decrease.
Gateway will soon work on newest firmware too.
Hey, NL readers/admins, here's a question for you: Is it still piracy if you only get a Gateway for Flipnote Studio 3D? (Yes, eShop games work, and FS3D is out there.) I mean, it's a free app!
And yes, people are resorting to piracy to get FS3D. #SorryNintendo but this is on you.
@zip you make a very good point there: i can't imagine there'd be any incentive to buy a new VC game if you've already got a rom and can emulate the system
personally, i still have my gameboy and GBA, and haven't rebought any VC games which i already own, because i find that most haven't aged well and i'd rather play newer games.
(i of course bought earthbound and some other classics which i missed the first time around)
the VC games which have really shone for me have been the ones that are impossible to emulate: the 3d classics, sega's especially.
hopefullly a silver lining to the cloud of reduced VC sales could be an increase in 3d remakes?
@eza Thanks for explaining that. I had read something about that a while back, but you explained it better than I would have.
@Sforzando heh, i believe that it's legally wrong (unauthorised duplication and distribution of copyrighted material) but morally right (unethical anticonsumerist creation of virtual barriers)
but morals are obviously personal, so it's for you to decide.
also just because something is legal doesn't mean that it is right - the law is tested and changes.
@9th_Sage my pleasure
@Ruppeeclock That's mine also. I have a blue XL I don't use anymore that I'll homebrew with if I can find Cubic Ninja anywhere.
@MikeLove I'm not really panicking. Not sure what in the tone of my message implied that I was. I've been very neutral in tone.
And the self-entitled donkeyhole circus continues... sad to see the Virtual Console die before it had any good chance to make a difference.
Please watch the profanity — TBD
I can only imagine the average-joe store employees are scratching their heads on why a game that's been out for over 3 years is selling like hot cakes all of a sudden.
I say let these people exercise their consumer right to play games region-free. If you own a game, you have every right to play it on your own console. This is what this will predominantly be used for... These doomsday predictions are rather pathetic.
@TrueWiiMaster you clearly know nothing of the exploit, then. somebody would need to develop a completely new exploit to open piracy for 3DS.
And as a note, NintendoLife, patching is unlikely. The studio is defunct, therefore meaning the source of the game is probably gone. It loads the exploit by loading a save file through the game that runs the homebrew code.The only way I can see Nintendo getting around this is disabling Cubic Ninja entirely... again, it's not out of the question, but very unlikely. And if Smealum found one way in? I'm positive he could find others, especially now that he's knowledgeable in the 3DS's architecture.
Aaaaaand bought. For $5. Hell yeah, go me. The place was really far for me though.
9,99 ere in holland
Welp with it announced at 5am the one of the 12 copies of Cubic Ninja in the UK stood no chance of being mine. Maybe next game. If there is one...
One thing is for sure Nintendo will try with patching. The obvious one is kill the exploit files on sight in the SD card (the solution is just don't have the SD card but does the 3DS generally like SD cards being inserted mid-gamplay).
Ultimately, they could blacklist the game from being launched or put it into some sort of sandbox. Both are very drastic though.
So how will nintendo know that people are pirating,
if someone plays this game more then 1 hour a year because the game sucks.
It's worse than I imagined... what a lousy bunch. The logic behind homebrew is the same as the logic behind having a rifle at home. It's just a pretentious case of "I do because I can, not because it's beneficial" bull.
@DGGames
It had a chance. Every week it gets a chance. Nintendo blew it, plain and simple. Many of us refuse to pay for the same games over and over again on multiple platforms with no hope of retention, even if the release schedule is acceptible, which it isn't.
@Kaze_Memaryu no the logic behind homebrew is nothing like the logic behind gun ownership, and if you don't see that then you could do with some logical thinking of your own.
the logic behind homebrew is "this is a cool device which i purchased and therefore own. i wonder what else i can get it to do?"
and what's wrong with that?
Got my copy for 10 bucks, haters gonna hate
@eza The fact that people violate the EULA they agreed to, for starters.
Homebrewers go "Screw the rules, they suck!" and then go break stuff. It's a ridiculous base to think of "possibilities" when they go into territory they're not authorized to tread in.
" while the eShop version is only an option in Japan." not true , there is a cart.
@DGGames
It doesn't. Read up before you flame others.
People on this website seriously need to do their research. This exploit can't lead to piracy because it doesn't allow kernel access. As someone who wants merely custom apps on his 3DS (although GBA/SNES games would be nice) I am thrilled for this and hope to get CN cheap so I can do it.
lol you cant download the game on the eshop.
@Kaze_Memaryu but EULAs are not legally binding contracts. nothing is signed or agreed to. search google for "are EULAs legally binding?" if you don't believe me.
it's a list of things that nintendo want you to abide by, but the law (at least in the EU and USA) says that once you purchase something then you own it.
the most that nintendo can do is to deny you access to their services, which they're obviously perfectly entitled to do.
but if you paid money for a physical product then the law says that you own that product, and can do what you like with it.
would you like to live in a world where companies can dictate how you can use their products? can take you to court if you use their product in a manner not intended?
or does it only apply when it's nintendo?
Wow my past self knew this game would come in handy in the future. Guess I'm ready to go then.
@Kaze_Memaryu If they want it binding (And to be taken seriously) they need to do it in the same way they do for devkits. (Side effect is there is no way I would sign an NDA type agreement prior to buying a console).
After reading a lot of your comments regarding the technical aspect of this little ninja's capabilities, does anyone with the knowledge regarding the matter know if this in some way can bypass the region lock ?
http://www.vgchartz.com/gamedb/?name=cubic+ninja
according to this site there are only 40K of these out there.
@CrabGats
So you're saying that it's entirely impossible for somebody to use the work this hacker has done to allow for piracy of 3DS games?
Ha, already have a copy
And so it begins...
Thanks for the update. I was finally able to unload my copy on ebay. Got $35 for it!
@eza It doesn't matter who or where, and it also doesn't matter if it's illegal or not - it's pathetic, nonetheless.
And unless companies actively restrict access to primary functions of a device, I'm fine with them telling me what I can and what I cannot do with stuff I buy from them.
Besides, I said this before and I'll say it again: nothing, absolutely NOTHING, homebrew stands for is worth opening the doors for piracy, period. I don't care whether smealum "locked" his HB installation to make it difficult for them, he still weakened the protection considerably, and pirates WILL use that to their advantage. Great thing every amateur can release their terrible game on a 3DS, now 500 people can tell him it's terrible, while 5.000 play Pokémon and Smash ROM's, while emulators kill the VC business without any withstanding quality.
"Some hackers are so obsessed with finding out if they could, that they never sat down to think if they should."
Slightly altered quote from Jurassic Park
@Kaze_Memaryu Can you read? He didn't "lock" anything, playing pirated 3DS games is just utterly impossible with this type of exploit. For piracy, there would have to be an exploit allowing access to the kernel. No need to lock it.
And if you don't like homebrew, fine, but why would you care about other people using it?
For those saying the developers don't mind, the game has been out of print for a while. Most sales are coming from used and second hand stores. Virtually all retailers clearance it out a while ago so they are seeing little return unless they decide to capitalize off the hype and start reprinting.
@felix330 Don't be delusional. Someone's gonna find the means, and Homebrew only makes it easier. That's guaranteed.
And with every user who jumps at this, hackers and modders are just gonna get even more fired up to mess around even further. The more people use Homebrew, the more the platform gets supported by all kinds of folks, and pirates are undoubtedly among them. And all that for some worthless "fame".
@Kaze_Memaryu that comparison makes no sense. More like owning a rifle and modifying it to use imported or home-made ammunition. And what is pretentious about homebrew? Maybe you're thinking of microbrews?
@Kaze_Memaryu i'm sorry, but you're simply wrong.
you're wrong about this exploit being able to lead to piracy.
smea didn't lock his exploit. nintendo locked their hardware.
you're wrong when you say it doesn't matter whether it's legal or illegal.
you're wrong when you say it's pathetic.
laws exist to specifically allow for reverse engineering. this is to encourage creativity and competition, and therefore to stimulate the economy, creating wealth.
without it, creativity is stifled, because creativity would become property of a company.
also, regarding piracy: the solution already exists and has been used to great effect by steam on the pc. if nintendo really wanted to stop piracy then they'd adopt valve's model: http://gamepolitics.com/2010/09/16/valve-piracy-rates-and-how-steam-keeps-them-low
"Once you create service value for customers, ongoing service value, piracy seems to disappear, right? It’s like “Oh, you’re still doing something for me? I don’t mind the fact that I paid for this.” Once you actually localise your product in Russia and ship it on the same day that you ship your English language versions, this theoretical hotbed of piracy becomes your second largest [market]" - gabe newell
@TeeJay I have never done anything "home brew" "emulator" related ever. I have been reading into how to do this for an old wii I acquired. Looking into doing same thing with an old ds. I have still been throwing money at Nintendo and will continue to if they keep doing the same thing they been for last 25+ years. Having a ds that runs emulators of ps1 games might not be legal I guess, but the thought of it is pretty cool. And I still have my 3ds that is downloading smashs' new update right now.
Nice i got my copy and am ready to go. Cant wait to pirate cubic ninja using cubic ninja
Lol, I bought that game for like $5 and traded it in for $8 a couple years ago. They should have tried to find an exploit in a game that's actually somewhat common.
@eza You can justify it all you want, the point stands: Homebrew endangers the security and integrity of platforms for pointless amateur work and playing ROM's.
Even if pirates cannot/will not use the Homebrew platform itself, they know how smealum managed to pull the stunt, and that's gonna make a full-on hack a simple matter of time.
Creativity has an abundance of platforms to thrive in, insisting one of the few platforms that expect actual professionalism is ludicrous. If people want to be creative freely, they can do it where they're welcome. No console manufacturer wants Homebrew on their platform, because so far, it ALWAYS ended up being more of a curse than thevfew things it's supposedly good for.
@Kaze_Memaryu i wasn't justifying anything, i was pointing the many ways in which you're wrong.
your point never stood and never will, because it's based on fallacies.
piracy has existed on the 3ds for quite some time now.
homebrew is not piracy.
pirates will see how smealum's hack works and will have no way to use it to run roms. they'll just carry on pirating with their gateway cards.
you're wrong, have no point, and you have no wish to educate yourself
I swear to whatever mothereffing god there is in the sky, the world needs to have less mules and sheep, because lord only knows what it would take to teach them anything.
On a less condescending but equally negative note, this game went for being $4 in value to $50 in less than 20 hours due to scalpers and that's disgraceful. Yet another ugly side of the homebrew world which just can't catch a clean break when it comes to reputation.
It always make me giggle incoherently when stuff like this happens, because everyone knows why the game is suddenly selling so it's hard to be mad about it.
@eza Taking things I said out of context doesn't help you in the slightest. I never said Homebrew IS piracy, I say it makes achieving piracy easier, which is fairly obvious, like it or not. Expanding upon this exploit will most likely be the base of hacks for eventually reaching full control. And even if it doesn't, smealum's success will give other hackers a push, since he proved that it's possible to run unsigned code in the first place.
@CrabGats "..as the company behind the game has folded, odds of the loophole being closed are practically non-existent."
...
Nintendo is counterattacking, no more eshop cubic ninja in japan.
@Kaze_Memaryu again, not true. just because homebrew on completely different systems has enabled piracy doesn't guarantee the same outcome on the 3ds.
it's a bit like the difference between windows xp and windows 7:
on win xp all processes have admin rights to do what they want. exploit a process and become admin.
on win7 only specific processes get admin rights. exploit a non-admin process and don't get anywhere.
older consoles are a bit like win xp, and hacking in gets you full admin control over everything.
the 3ds is more like win7, where hacking a non-privileged process will only get you limited access, and the core system is still protected.
look, i know where you're coming from: you don't want to see rampant piracy on the 3ds, of course you don't, and that's admirable. but you've taken those fears and drawn a conclusion based on the history of other systems, while at the same time ignoring the facts of this specific situation.
you're unwilling to concede the possibility that homebrew can exist without allowing privacy.
your point comes down to "let's stifle creativity and prevent learning because pirates (who have been able to run roms for ages now) will take this exploit and (in a way that you don't explain) magically change it to access parts of the system that it cannot access. because it has happened before and therefore will happen again."
you're generalising and overly simplifying, and it's not helpful. your other option is to go and read about these issues in detail and educate yourself.
Still have it, got it pretty early, and had some enjoyment with it.
I only recently soft-modded my Wii, mostly to emulate fan-translation-patched roms like Sweet Home (Famicom), Mother 3 (which I own on GBA originally, but it's Japanese obviously),... and to play imported games from non-PAL regions, that never got released here, like Kirby's Dream Collection, Excitebots, Zero 4 with the fan-translation,...
May do the same with one of my 3DSes in time.
@andrea987 Pretty sure that was edited in. I wouldn't have explained it had it been there in the first place, plus the first paragraph still implies that it would be a simple patch to the 3DS's operating system.
Haha! Good thing I guessed right and ordered it back before the New 3DS
announcement!
With regards to patching, as far as I know, several exploits are used in
order for the Homebrew Channel to work, Cubic Ninja is just the entry point.
So there's room to patch the firmware to prevent one of those exploits.
Which they'll probably do within a few days after the release, I guess...
Again, this exploit cannot directly lead to piracy. It certainly exposes
a greater attack surface (now that you can actually execute code on the
system) but it is not enough to run ROMs of retail games. It's not "locked
down" to prevent it, it just can't. Unless someone finds new huge bugs and
write new exploits on top of it, which would probably amount to at least
the same amount of work that was needed to get homebrew in the first place.
If piracy is your goal, there are other ways that are much more likely to
work with less effort (I can think of two products that allegedly already
work and take two very different approaches: one gets full access on the
system, the other emulates cartridges).
Regarding emulation... emulating something you've backed up yourself is
perfectly legal in most places... although I doubt many people actually do
that (it's easy with Wii/GC, but hm, it's a bit more invovled for SNES and
stuff). Emulating games you haven't backed up yourself is clearly illegal,
and causes some harm to Nintendo, indeed.
If Nintendo released more VC games Id buy them, especially GBA and SNES titles. If they don't and someone wants to hack the system to play it then more power to em.
Woke up early for work and saw the tweet about cubic ninja the other day, bought it on Amazon UK for £10 before the news broke properly.
Happy days.
A pity that this game only sells because people need it for the Homebrew channel. The game wasn't intended for this!
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...