Talisman is a superb board game that conjures forth innumerable fond memories. The vast multitude of characters to choose from, each more unbalanced than the last. The hundreds upon hundreds of Adventure Cards offering something new to see on every play. Spellcasting battles leading to pure salt from the eventual loser. It’s an absolute classic, and Talisman: Digital Edition is a worthy, content-rich adaptation.
The central premise of Talisman is a quest to acquire the Crown of Command, an artefact guarded by a powerful and fearsome dragon. To defeat the dragon and claim the Crown, players must journey through an expansive world building up their character (chosen from a variety of fantasy archetypes and each with different skills), exchanging the experience earned from defeated monsters for additional “strength” and “craft” tokens. You’ll pick up useful items that enhance your abilities, gain followers who can assist in battle or carry your belongings, and learn devastating spells to help turn the tides. Most importantly, however, is the titular Talisman, which allows you to bypass an otherwise devastating obstacle on the way to the dragon. So basically – gain power, get Talisman, kill dragon, wear Crown, win.
It’s impossible to dance around the fact that Talisman is very much a game of luck. There’s a lot of stuff bolted onto it, sure, but most situations are still resolved by dice rolls and crossed fingers. All combat is resolved this way, ditto traversal. We’ve had sessions with the physical version of the board game that came down to a simple “roll a 5 or 6 to win the game”, and that’s not ideal. However, it’s a problem endemic of Talisman, so it would be churlish to criticise this digital version for accurately representing its source game.
And it certainly does represent it accurately, all the way down to its absurd number of expansions, offered here as expensive DLC. The base game comes with three additional expansions as standard (The City, The Sacred Pool and The Frostmarch), but it’s a little bit galling just how much more there is to buy and how much it’d set you back to have a fully decked-out game. That said, it’s still an order of magnitude cheaper than any given physical board game of its nature. Whether or not you indulge in the DLC, you’re getting plenty of game for your money here.
The presentation of Talisman: Digital Edition is very good, though its UI is a little complex at first. This is understandable when you’re converting a game with as many pieces as Talisman, where any information you may need in the physical version is more or less available to you at a glance. Here, on Switch, navigation is a little less intuitive, but once you pick it up you’ll be soaring along. Gameplay is pacey and as attractive as it needs to be without sacrificing accessibility or obfuscating essential information; the state of the board is always clear and everything you need to make informed decisions is available at the touch of a button.
“Hot seat” style play is available, with you passing the Switch between your friends, alongside the more traditional multiplayer gameplay with everyone using their own controller. In a welcome addition, there’s also cross-platform online play, so you’ll be able to play with friends on the Steam, Android and iOS versions. Ultimately, it’s an extremely well-made conversion of a beloved board game to a system that’s pretty much perfect for it. The only real caveats are the excess of DLC and – let’s face it – the fairly unbalanced gameplay of the original Talisman. It’s a wonderful version of a game we love, but if you demand an absolutely level playing field in your entertainment, you may want to knock a point or two off this score.
Comments 19
It's a pretty fun board game from what I remember. If the game and all of its expansions ever goes on sale really cheap I'll grab it but right now the price to get everything is way beyond what I'd ever consider paying.
I'm waiting for Wingspan coming this spring! 🦅
@Maboo Yep, superb game!
That looks kinda cool actually.
Just a shame its bit too expensive for an impulse buy.
And all the DLC seems very predatory.
An 8 is better than I expected. I may have to grab this and give it a go during this period of isolation. A diverse array of genre types should keep me satisfied during this time. Maybe.
@Kiz3000 for what it is, an 8 is deserved. I played it a lot on steam and it was a blast. Just don't go in thinking it's a comparable 8 to those of triple A games.
Does it have DLC for the Kingdom Hearts version? Doubt it but that would be a selling point for me.
"Extremely luck-based"
Ah, forget it then. I hate games where your fortunes are dependent not on skilled play but on the roll of the dice.
It's a really super nice adaptation of an already super fun board game. Although, as usual, wait for a steep discount, as the Nintendo tax is pretty HEAVY on this one. It's $25 here on the Switch store, while it's $8 on Steam and $5 on Android for the exact same game.
I don't think it's worth paying an extra $20 just for controller support. But get it elsewhere if it seems interesting to you. Because it's fun. Just not worth the Nintendo Tax.
Knowing how much luck is involved, I’ll probably pass.
@Brady1138 Yeah that is always my problem with these type of games, your success is really dependent upon the luck of the draw.
What would be nice to know is if the DLC is cross buy like it is on other platforms
@shaneoh It isn't, sadly.
@StuartGipp
That's disappointing, maybe further down the track when they're trying to sell more copies. Cheers.
Played the mobile version probably... 100 times. And we often meet up for the analogue version. I've played it since the 90s. Talisman is a great game because it's so accessible. I always saw it as a board game version of a rougelike. You can get good at it but there's still a chance you'll get screwed over by a falling boulder or something.
Praying somebody does a physical with the DLC, or some of it at least.
I have played the PC version of this. I guess if you like Talisman it’s great, but that means you have terrible taste in board games or heavy nostalgia glasses
To me "Extremely luck-based" is a pro hahah.
I don't want to leave a bad review, as it's pretty decent. However some of the expansions, realm of souls, harbinger etc; that have board terrains simply don't work. You just get the original board. The cards and characters do appear though. Has anyone else experienced this?
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...