Say what you will about 2K Sports, but it certainly knows how to get the most out of the Switch hardware. NBA 2K21 is the fourth of its basketball games to find its way onto Nintendo’s system, and by this point, the spectre of NBA 2K18’s botched launch is a distant memory; these days, the series looks tremendous on Switch, and 2K21 is no different.
On the court, the main difference this year is a complete overhaul of the right stick shooting system. In the past, you would shoot by either pressing the Y button or moving the right stick in a certain direction, with the tried-and-tested basketball game method of releasing the button at just the right time to determine how accurate your shot is. This year, you can still do this with some tinkering in the options menu, but the new default is a completely new method.
This time, holding down the right stick to shoot will bring up a shot meter with a little coloured target section in it. You have to gently move the stick left or right to place your cursor in the middle of this target section before the shot is released in order to throw the ball straight. If the cursor is to either side of the target, your shot will be slightly off-centre, affecting its chances of going in (depending on how far off you were, of course). Naturally, more difficult shots are trickier to line up in time.
It’s an interesting new shot system but it takes a little practice to get used to, especially if you’re a long-time basketball game fan who’s potentially spent decades holding down a shot button and releasing it at the right time, and now have to adapt to a new system where you also have to worry about balance is a bit like patting your head and rubbing your belly at the same time. At least it’s better than it was at launch; following complaints that it was far too difficult to pull off an accurate shot, 2K has added an update that makes things easier in Rookie, Pro and All-Star difficulty levels. Now it’s noticeably more forgiving, but will still take some getting used to regardless – and if you really can’t get along with it, you can turn it off in the Options menu.
This new shooting system aside, the rest of the game feels much the same as last year’s effort. There have been odd tweaks here and there as is always the case with annual sports releases, but nothing quite as revolutionary as the right stick revamp. Most of the other changes, then, are in the game modes: most notably the MyPlayer story mode and the MyTeam mode (where, as ever, you create your own dream team from scratch).
The story in MyPlayer this year is more restrained than it has been in previous years and follows a more conventional path to the top. Every year your created protagonist is given a nickname and a backstory: in 2K21 you’re playing as Junior, a high school American football player who reluctantly turns to basketball despite knowing he’ll be living in the shadow of Duke, his deceased father and former basketball legend. Naturally, you can expect a lot of “that was my dad, it isn’t me” banter as well as other sports movie cliches like potentially questionable agents, love interests, pesky journalists and rival players on other teams.
Despite being a relatively tame story, it's one of the more engaging ones in recent years, and the acting is of a generally higher quality than what we've seen in some previous years. The Switch struggles a bit during the cutscenes, though; while 2K generally does a phenomenal job elsewhere in the game – on the court it's usually a solid 30 frames per second and the level of detail is fantastic for Nintendo's system – the MyPlayer cutscenes suffer from some severe frame rate drops and general glitching. It's a shame because it does distract from the plot, but there you go.
In terms of progression, Junior starts off playing for his high school team, the Newark East Eagles. Games are played in gym halls with crowds of a few hundred and the commentary is provided by a suitably youthful sounding pair of presumably pimple-faced teens. Your performance in the handful of high school games you play will determine which colleges are interested in you; before long, you’ll be headed to one of ten (real-life) college teams, ranging from the likes of Michigan State and UCL to Gonzaga and Villanova. Naturally, the way you play during this college season will then have an impact on which round of the NBA draft you’re likely to be chosen in, which NBA team you may end up going to and what your likely salary per game will be.
It’s this last element that’s perhaps the most crucial because as with previous MyPlayer modes in the past, there’s a heavy focus on virtual currency (VC) here. As ever, your player will start off with lousy stats and can increase them with VC; this can either be earned through in-game grinding or bought with real money. This is far from the first time 2K players have been offered this decision; you can either spend a long time slowly building your player’s stats (which is ultimately more rewarding but will take a while) or you can drop £40-50 and boost their stats to something far more impressive right away.
VC also has an impact on MyTeam, 2K21’s other big mode. If you aren’t familiar with it, it’s essentially the NBA 2K series’ version of FIFA’s Ultimate Team mode; starting off with a basic team, you play games and take on challenges to earn currency that can then be spent on random packs of player (i.e. loot boxes) or on specific players in an auction house. As in MyPlayer, you can either earn VC by playing or by just chucking your wallet at the game. VC is interchangeable between modes, too, so it’s possible to earn some playing MyPlayer and spend it on MyTeam and vice versa.
To be fair to MyTeam, it’s undergone a big transformation this year and now includes the latest gaming trend: Seasons. As in most other season-based games, this mode is now split into periods of 40+ days, during which time you can gain XP for playing certain match types and accomplishing certain requirements. Each time you pass certain XP targets you’ll hit a new level and unlock a new freebie: this could be a card pack, a power-up or something more special like a unique player. If you can reach level 40 by the end of season one, for example, you’ll get a special 96-rated reward version of Steph Curry.
(Incidentally, FIFA 20 added a Seasons mode too, but it wasn't on the Switch version because EA has seemingly given up supporting the system. Say what you will about 2K's heavy-handedness when it comes to infusing microtransactions throughout its games, but at least it goes to the effort to make sure the Switch version has practically full feature parity with those on more powerful systems.)
The addition of Seasons to MyTeam makes it far less of a mindless grind because there’s always a new reward not too far away if you continue to play. Obviously, though, it also brings with it a new set of modern-day gaming problems, like the ‘FOMO’ effect; if you can’t reach level 40 by the end of the season (the first one ends sometime in mid-October) you won’t ever get that Steph Curry card. You might need a boost to get there, so hey, why not chuck a few quid at us to boost your team a bit? And so the microtransaction train continues to hurtle along.
If you’re the type of player who can happily resist the pressure of microtransactions and the somewhat grimy feeling that seeps throughout the game as a result of this, NBA 2K21 is still a fantastic basketball game. Its new shooting system will prove divisive but the fact it’s optional in most modes means it’s not a game-breaker by any means. Other than that, it’s business as usual.
MyPlayer is still a marathon rather than a sprint: your player still takes potentially months of regular play to develop into a superstar, and it’s still greatly satisfying if you can reach that level without getting your credit card out to speed up the process. MyTeam is still an engaging mode (even more so with Seasons) that feels similarly rewarding if you can stick with it long enough to build up a team of all-stars without ever bothering your bank account. And – most importantly of all – on the court, the level of presentation, the quality of the visuals on Switch and the feel of the game, in general, are all still without equal when it comes to basketball video games.
Conclusion
With a solid new story mode, a greatly improved MyTeam mode and the same high quality of presentation that 2K now brings to the series on Switch, NBA 2K21 is now the new definitive basketball game on the system. The unwanted microtransaction ogre continues to loom over most of the package, ever encouraging you to fork out more cash to accelerate your progress, but as long as you're capable of ignoring this and have the patience to slowly improve your player and team organically, the results will be infinitely more satisfying.
Comments 94
Well it’s certainly basketball. I enjoyed the games a few years ago but I don’t spend money on MTX so definitely hit a wall when it came to progress as I couldn’t keep up with it. Hopefully when MLB The Show goes multiplat it comes on Switch, it has the fairest monetisation of any sports game I’ve played.
You want us to ignore the main thing ruining the game for a lot of people?
Not for me but sounds really solid.
That is the whole problem. You can't ignore the stinging Micro transactions!
It's bulls@hit having to pay full retail price for a game and then having it riddled with Micro transactions like the typical trash F2P mobile game!
The “The game is still built around encouraging you to spend cash to speed up progress” Con, should take a lot more points off then 2.
The NBA games are littered with opportunities to spend more money on top of the outrageous 60$ price tag.
I figured the actual gameplay would be good. Still disappointed in the mtx, though.
"Ignore The Microtransactions"
Yeah, no thanks. I'd rather just ignore the game.
Don't mind me, I'm just here to applaud the latest Scullion Sub-Header (TM) 👌🏻
Who cares when NBA Jam exists?
Wasnt a huge fan of the last game. Couldn't get the hang of the gameplay. Will probably buy this in 11 months when it's on sale for €3 again.
I remember in 2K18 story mode, had the bonus upgrade points from preorder, only to squander them without knowing what I was doing. Had to restart my save after corruption early on, only to learn I couldn't get those points back. Then, when I was able to design my own shoe for Under Armour, I quickly realized I wouldn't be able to afford them anytime soon as I had to purchase them for a ridiculous price afterwards. I soldiered on, but man was the progression painfully slow. I didn't even bother with online multiplayer stuff as my rating was awful compared to so many other players. I eventually didn't bother with story and just did regular season mode. The game was pretty solid outside of story mode.
to be honest and quite frankly, this graphics and this game could be running easy easy on Xbox 360. Nintendo need to make improvements to your hardware as fast as shark
I am not a fan of sports video games but this game is without a doubt the best-looking basketball game I've ever seen running on a handheld
I am still running 2K19 simply because I love that season and I don't really don't see how this is much better than that.
I know I'm old school, but I wish they would monetise these games as either a full price product, everything included, or as free-to-play. I realize they'll keep milking the cow as long as they can, but there is so MUCH consumer resentment building up over these microtransactions.
i borrowed my friend's copy and did not like it at all. the new shot meter, even with the right analog stick or using buttons, is horrible, and i'm missing every open jump shot that i should be getting, as well as missing free throws.
plus not enough changed to make me pay $60 for this game. i'm pretty happy with NBA 2k20 for now
@JayJ not sure if it's still available but i know 2k20 was $4.99 recently on the eshop.
@SalvorHardin Heck, I still have my Dreamcast for NFL Blitz. Those Midway games were the best way to enjoy sports AND have a laugh riot with my friends.
I can’t believe this was the first game to try and squeeze 70 dollars out of people. Why 60+ dollar games are allowed to have micro transactions is beyond me when people are incredibly quick to have loot boxes regulated by the government.
@Mchi5 Yeah I saw that but I didn't go for it as I still prefer the prior season teams and the game took up even more space, which is an issue when 19 already took up a ton of space. Honestly these games never seem to improve much year to year. I had 2K18 before I got 2K19 and I barely noticed any improvement at all, it just isn't worth it to get these games every year.
Nope. I won't buy. Shameless crap like microtransactions are a huge no no for me. I didn't pay 5 bux for the last one just because of this and it was only 5 bux.
They have the audacity to fill the game with in-app transactions (they are hardly "micro") and yet they STILL won't issue the full game on cartridge.
Ignore the microtransactions? Nah ill just ignore the game. Perhaps if sites like this did the same they'd stop peddling this *****.
@nessisonett MLB The Show is going multiplatform? I thought Sony had the deal for seemingly as long as they wanted. Would love a good baseball game on Switch.
Shame the review doesn't come down harsher on the predatory microtransaction and gambling mechanics but expected as much.
Sounds great! I look forward to paying $5 for it, this time next year. Until they chill with the mtx, I wont support it new.
@BeautyandtheBeer Yeah, as of next game, it was announced it’s going to Xbox and PC. No Switch announcement as of yet but to be fair, a lot of games hedge their bets with Switch until they’re sure they can develop a full port. The community have been really positive about it as the extra revenue means Sony could get the licenses for legends from leagues like the Negro Leagues and Mexican Leagues and (hopefully but a long shot) legends affected by the whole doping scandal fiasco. The only people annoyed about it are PS4 players who have never played the series that have an aneurysm when they see games like Horizon and Death Stranding going onto PC. It’s the death of Playstation, didn’t you know 😛
@JayJ I agree with you. I did like some of the changes and visual improvements from 2k19 to 2k20 but overall not much has changed
I thought it was just the switch so I even downloaded the demo for 2k21 on my PS4. Nope still pretty trash haha
If it has micro transactions I won’t even look at the game
Here is my Sonic 06 review. Ignore the bugs, convoluted story, Mach speed sections, long loading screens, annoying side missions, horrible controls, awful camera, lack of speed, broken puzzles, and you’ve got one of the best Sonic games out there!
@nessisonett Oh nice, did not know that. Think my hopes for a Switch version are mixed as sports games seem to skip Switch (EA doesn't care, 2K do but prey on you). At least on Xbox though.
Faeces: ignore the taste and smell, and you've got the cheapest sandwich filling around.
I can’t bear to even have any game with micro transactions on my console - I’m totally allergic to them. I really hope the games industry ditches this bad practice for good.
"The game is still built around encouraging you to spend cash to speed up progress"
810
what the hell
Does anyone happen to know if MyLeague works online with friends in this game? I got 2K18 and 2K19 when they went on deep sales, but could never get MyLeague online to work for either game. There are mixed reports as to whether or not the mode even exists in Switch editions of 2K.
Has anyone gotten MyLeague online to work for either this game or any other 2K game on Switch?
"Ignore The Microtransactions And You've Got The Best Basketball Game On Switch"
..lol what a weird opinion .....I will be ignoring every bads that videogames have, thus all the videogames will be the best 10/10
That headline is disgusting.
That's like adverting a house as the perfect place to live in-spite of it's massive rat infestation.
What about "Aggressive micro-transactions ruin what would be the best basketball game on the Switch?" You need to take responsibility, Nintendolife.
they know their user base will buy it anyway because they love the game, so they decide to abuse them with those micro-transactions. For me they can burn in hell slowly.
I'm torn here. On one hand, I get that the game seems to be pretty good, and gameplay is the most important thing. On the other hand, microtransactions should be snuffed out. From an ethical standpoint it feels like the game should be docked a few points for such anti-consumer nonsense.
Ignore the microtransactions. I'll probably ignore the entire game until it's marked down to $4.99 next summer.
And why do they have to mess with the jump shot controls? It's been that way since Double Dribble. Leave that alone. Is nothing sacred anymore?
Micro-transactions fundamentally affect the way a game is designed, so are impossible to ignore. Well, that’s not quite true, I can ignore them by not purchasing the game
I’ll wait until it’s 99p like the last one.
I wish they would have been more specific about "if you ignore the microtransations." I have some games like FarCry 5 and Devil May Cry V that have microtransations, but I never felt like I was missing out on anything by ignoring them. On the other end is FIFA, where it seems you're not really playing unless you feed it money though as EA would say, you don't HAVE to buy loot boxes. Sure, you don't NEED butter and garlic to eat escargot, but could you really stomach the pile of snails without it?
Another 8/10 game everyone is going to avoid. Hurray. Go Nintendo Life!
It's a shame two of the biggest advocates for mtx make the sports games. We just need Activision to make a baseball game and the trifecta will be complete. 🙄
Hopefully the Show does indeed come to Switch, Nintendo retweeted the announcement of the series going 3rd party, so there's hope.
Why is noone even mentioning the fact that for the story mode (MyCareer) you must be online AT ALL TIMES. Also, when you do play in handheld mode on wifi, if you put your game to sleep, you auto disconnect and all your time in game was a waste. I thought we could play "on the go" with this console? I guess not, unless you have internet everywhere, at all times.
At least the file size on this one is a bit more reasonable?
Played the demo and was seriously blown away by how it looked.
I think 2K get's a bit too much ***** for the MTX that don't really appear if you don't want them to.
I also just played Bioshock 3 today for the first time. And man what a spectacular port. Especially considering that it is Unreal Engine, which got such an high amount of really bad ports.
I think 2K really delivers on their "2K loves Switch" promise if you ask me.
They don't ***** us over and they put work and care in their releases.
All of you bitching about an objectively quality release is not helping to get more third party support.
@KryptoniteKrunch Can't wait for The Show. RBI20 is not as bad as people say it is, but it still doesn't cut it in the long run.
@Yanina I don't think reasonable complaints aimed at the way the game is riddled with microtransactions is bitching. And I hardly think it will affect third party support. We're over 3 years into the life cycle and third party support is great.
@nintendope64 But the thing is that I think it is not really as bad as people make it sound. It is literally just one specific mode. The meat of the game is free from MTX.
I feel like most people just jump on a hate train and exaggerating.
And don't get me wrong, of course I would prefer a game free from MTX. Especially at that price range.
But nobody complains about skins and lootboxes in Overwatch. Completely optional. I don't see why it is SUCH a big deal here.
Same with FIFA. Played for like 100 hours and never even realized it has some mode with MTX.
Why don't just make it free to play...??
@the_beaver Because they won't be able to get extra money.
@TheFox To be fair, I was pretty specific about how the microtransactions are used in the actual review.
If the game is good in all other regards and you can progress in a sensible way without micro-transactions I don't see it as a huge problem for me. I'd prefer they weren't there, and I understand why some people will avoid the game on principle, but I can ignore them and enjoy the game anyway.
I put in hundreds of hours every year with sports games since 2001, even though I'm a big Nintendo guy, so I appreciate it when quality comes out on a Nintendo system.
@BeautyandtheBeer @nessisonett When it was first announced to go multiplatform Nintendo did tweet out that news so if anything perhaps they have to make it work. I even said I wouldn't care if it was a direct port from the PS3 version. It would still be the best Baseball games on the system.
@the_beaver While this would be the best thing to do consumer-wise, 2K would rather see how much money they can earn from their hardcore fans before lowering the price or making it free for everyone else. That way, they max out on profits and keep their pockets as big as their greed
@Spoony_Tech Yeah, the player models have barely changed this whole gen anyway! Still, I sank over 200 hours in lockdown into the online mode without spending a penny. I have a team filled with true legends like Jackie Robinson and Babe Ruth and while I haven’t quite collected every player to unlock Mickey Mantle, I’m not too far off either. Their MTX strategy is pretty great, give shortcuts to lazy players or let players earn the rewards through gameplay.
Used to love these games on other consoles as a kid picked up 20 for 99 cents and... it kind of sucked on switch. A mess for me not sure what other people experience but it was a glitchy mess for me
@scully1888 I read it again to be certain I didn't miss anything. And yes, you did a very good job explaining how they work, and I appreciate that. But the devil is in the details, or in this case, two specific details: 40-50 pounds, or grind for a while. "A while" could mean something reasonable, or it could be a nice way of saying, "It will take forever!" Also, until you unlock a selection of good players in MyTeam, are you seriously crippled, or can you have a fair shot of winning with an starter team?
Con: “The game is still built around encouraging you to spend cash to speed up progress”
Sorry, but this alone is enough to dock anything from 4-6 points minimum. A game is meant to entertain, not a method with which to entice you to spend yet more money after already buying it. It is literally the antithesis of gaming and entertainment with the exception of one example...gambling. The only form of entertainment I can think of where spending money and enticing you to spend more directly as part of the “entertainment”.
This isn’t a game; it’s a con job disguised as one!
I'm glad EA doesn't make this game.
If they did it would remove the extra modes and the microtransactions.
Everyone here would be mad, but for a different reason.
For me, I LOVE the 2K series.
The gameplay is easily the best basketball out there, ever.
Even if it falls short of real basketball (often and stupidly). It's just an impossible bar.
For me I don't play MyPlayer or MyTeam.
I play franchise - it is an amazing mode of incredible depth.
I have put dozens of hours into it in each of the 2K games I've bought.
Is it an 8?
Well for me it is a 9 or 10 - rarely do I play games as much as this game. I have TONS of sport games, most of them break down pretty quickly. They don't scale with your abilities, they end up being shallow and easily broken by mechanics that aren't well thought out for LONG TERM play.
NBA2K is the antithesis.
There is tons of long-term play, you can almost always get better, and then go online for more play.
If you want the RPG mode or the myteam mode, you may have a different experience.
That said, I wonder if they should sell them as 3 different games?
Each one I think is worth the price of entry for the right player.
For me, I agree with the review, but would score it higher.
If you like NBA - this is an awesome game, literally the best, hands down, and not just the best NBA game, it's one of the best 2 sport games around (the show is the only one that is better).
I don't get it, we all know it's a gross, exploitative excuse for a game that should be free to play at best. Is it really worth sacrificing your integrity as a site just to get a few free copies of games in the future? I've got nothing against the reviewer as they are just doing a job, but surely it would be better for the site, the readers and the industry on the whole if you waited a bit, bought a copy and let them have it with a genuine review. If the review sites aren't careful they're going to end up with a job they hate and a gaming industry full of games like this.
Hiding behind the whole 'As a game it's very solid and without all the negative, predatory microtransactions it deserves a solid score.' nonsense doesn't cut it. The game does have all those negative aspects to it and should be scored accordingly.
I just wish it didn't take up so much space, even with a cartridge....
I say this every single year. Yes you can enjoy this game easily without every thinking about micro transactions. MyGM mode will give you a great basketball sim with no micro transaction in sight.
@Roger_Brazil Then you don't remember Xbox360 well.
@kobashi100 Yes. It honestly get's ridiculous. I am sure most people complaining never played one of the games.
Fire Emblem has a lot of DLC stuff. Nobody complains about the game being a scam or incomplete without it. Just to hit directly in the Nintendo-nerve.
Don't want to pay for the DLC? Then don't play the DLC. (Fire Emblem)
Don't want MTX? Then don't play this one single mode nobody cares about anyway. (NBA)
Sorry Chris you have proven to be far too forgiving for games built around microtransactions such as your MK Tour review so this is a no go for me.
This ***** should be challenged not accepted.
@0nett 🤣 so does that same mentality work for other game reviews;
Ignore the terrible camera 8/10
Ignore the unresponsive controls 8/10
Ignore the game breaking bugs 9/10
@Old-Red I thought they would subtract points off the score for each negative
@Yanina Yeah, the DLC in Fire Emblem games literally allows you to grind extremely easily for a fee. Never see that complained about though!
Not usually the type to even leave a review, but unless switch is your only option for this id say pass. been playing the series since 2k with Allen Iverson on the cover, this is a horrible version , the shot stick is completely broken. save your money wait till around black Friday when its five bucks
@scully1888 How much money did 2K bribe you to say positive things and it a good score? Besides why should I buy any sport games in this day in age. They are not getting a single cent from me as long as whiny athlete losers who are doing the Anti-American kneeling during the National Anthem and supportive of that faceless rioter/anarchists.
Predatory micro transactions = I’ll avoid this game like the plague.
@JereJK It makes sense, I guess...
@Old-Red @LaytonPuzzle27 Right. Listen.
I have no issue with people disagreeing with a score but I draw the line at "how much money did 2K bribe you" and accusations that I "sacrificed my integrity" to get "more free games in the future". That's just absolute nonsense.
Reviews are supposed to break down in detail the elements of a game so that the reader can take them all into account and decide for themselves whether it sounds like the sort of thing they'd like. It isn't just about the number at the end.
I address the microtransactions in detail in the review. I refer to them in the conclusion as an "unwanted ogre" and say elsewhere that they create a "grimy" feeling. I mention them in seven separate paragraphs. Nothing is being hidden here.
However, I also make it clear that, whether you want to hear it or not, it's perfectly playable to play the game without them. I've been playing this series since the Dreamcast days (mostly paying for them, thanks very much) and I haven't spent a single penny on microtransactions at any point, yet still come back every year because it simply plays a fun game of basketball. In a way, they're so ridiculously overpriced in this particular series that it's very easy to ignore them, because there's nothing really 'micro' about them: these aren't impulse purchases like they would be in mobile games.
Ultimately, reviews are supposed to be consumer advice for people trying to decide whether to make a purchase. The issue here is that the people protesting and asking for scores of 3 and 4 because of the microtransactions were never going to buy the game in the first place, so why should I be providing a 'protest' score that doesn't actually help people interested in the game?
On the court is where it mainly counts, and on the court this is a brilliant game (now that the shooting has been fixed). It's an 8. You should be capable of reading the review and reading about the microtransactions: if you decide that's too much for you then just don't buy the thing. The score isn't a contract, it's advice you – taking into account the information in the 1300 words above it – can either take or leave. Other people, however, will accept that it's perfectly possible to play the game without playing 2K's 'game' and without paying extra. Those people will buy the game, keep their wallet away and still have a good time with it.
Hope that explains things better. Please give it a rest with the bribe nonsense.
Removed - unconstructive feedback
Given how little they change in these annual releases, and the fact that they drop the price to about £1.99 towards the end of each season, I have no idea who goes out and buys these games at full price on launch.
@scully1888 Ignore the bribe junk, people are obsessed with all journos being corrupt, because some anonymous commenter on the internet told them it's so.
Genuine question though - If the game is much the same as last year - a game that was recently available for the price of a sandwich - do you feel the new game genuinely contains enough new content to command a £50 price tag? This site was very harsh on the last FIFA game for being essentially identical to the previous year's game.
@scully1888 What's the point of doing a review if you are only going to cherry pick the positives and ignore the negatives in the score? As far as I'm concerned, that's not a review.
The game forces you to drudge through a tedious grind or pony up = 8/10. Not sure who you're trying to convince, us or yourself.
@Old-Red With respect, it sounds like you're trying to convince me that I said something I didn't. I never mentioned anything about a "tedious grind" - I said you either take time playing the thing and earn your stats that way or pay up to speed things up, and I think it's fairly clear by the language used in the review that I don't approve of the latter.
I never said the grind was "tedious", only that it takes a while. You're still playing what I firmly believe is an excellent basketball game to get there and you're still making progress through the leagues while you do it, it's not like an RPG where you're just running back and forth over the same bit of land to level up.
You're accusing me of "cherry picking the positives and ignoring the negatives", when the reality is you're doing the exact opposite: you're completely ignoring that I think the game itself is great fun to play because you're focusing 100% of your attention on an element of the game that, while certainly a negative, is absolutely not necessary to play it.
If you don't like the fact that microtransactions are in the game and you want to take a principled stance against them then fine, don't play it. But other people understand that these things, while toxic, affect different games in different ways, and the reality is that they can absolutely be avoided here. It's not a case of "ignoring the negatives": as stated above, I mention them numerous times in the article. I just don't think they 'weigh' as much as the positives because they can be ignored in the game. If the thing was practically broken unless you paid extra then you'd see a much lower score.
@BionicDodo I was harsh on FIFA because it literally was the same game as last year's with just the squads updated. That isn't the case with this one: MyPlayer and MyTeam, the two main modes, are completely different. Hope that helps clarify it!
@scully1888 I normally try an avoid this kind of conversation online. I try to go by the rule of not writing a comment that I wouldn't say to someone's face, but when it comes to monetisation like this I find it hard to hold back.
The fact that I didn't even realise it was you who reviewed this game until you replied and I had similar issues with another review you did recently goes to show that I simply don't agree with how you review or rate games. I guess that's all we can take from this really.
@scully1888 Thanks for clarifying.
@Old-Red I guess so. I can definitely live with that.
@scully1888 Am very sorry for accusing you.
@Cosatsof course i remember and when i am seeing this kind of game, i can bet, this a shY6t, including what they have done with MK11...please take me out
@Yanina I understand why it might be seen as overblown, but as the writer said himself, he mentioned it in seven paragraphs. And one of the cons literally says that the game is built around the microtransactions.
While I'm well aware the gameplay might be solid, I think it's a bit rich of the writer and anyone defending the stance to be so unrelenting. It doesn't take much to see other people's points. A simple "I understand why you'd think it should lose a few points" would go a long way. It's a video game review at the end of the day, not some holy grail of work that will be archived and critically revisited for years to come.
Like someone said previously, these kinds of practices are to be fought in the industry if we're going to make any sort of consumer friendly progress. Giving this an 8/10 does nothing to help the downturn and constant monetization of a once awesome pastime.
@Old-Red IGN wrote a much better review where they were much more realistic about the encroaching microtransactions. They pointed out that minor gameplay tweaks aren't good enough when the game is so blatantly plagued by this BS. Gave it a 6/10 as a result. Great to see a major site that's not afraid to do that.
Not bad if you get the bigger edition and get the extras as well.
@Jeronan It depends on the game. If the microtransactions are only for speeding up progress that can eventually be done for free, then they're perfectly ignorable. I've been playing "Pokémon Shuffle" and "Pokémon Rumble World" on my 3DS for years without spending a cent or ever being tempted to do so.
@SalvorHardin True, but the Switch doesn't currently have access to an "NBA Jam" game. However, if you can still play one of them on SNES, Genesis/MegaDrive, 32X, Wii, or Wii U (via backwards compatibility), then go right ahead and ignore this game.
An 8 out 10 for this pile of crap.
Well a few months down the line and I pulled the trigger on this game when I saw it on sale for $20. I loved playing and watching basketball in real life when I was younger but I just know nothing about the NBA now. I'm going to be watching games, listening to podcasts, and playing this game a bit to get me back into the sport.
Microtransactions can eat dirt, I'll be playing the single-player content.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...